Friday 04 July 2008 OTTAWA: BANKS MILDLY UPBEAT ON ECONOMY
The Royal Bank of Canada and the Bank of Montreal have issued moderately optimistic economic forecasts. The reports follow the negative growth in the first quarter. Royal Bank predicts yearly growth of 1.4 per cent and 2.5 per cent in 2009. BMO sees one per cent growth this year and 2.2 in the next. Both banks sees difficult times for Ontario and Quebec because of the high Canadian dollar, weak U.S. demand for imports and high energy prices. Ontario's finance ministry earlier on Thursday reported negative growth of .3 per cent for the first quarter. Despite the woes of central Canada's manufacturing sector, Royal Bank and BMO report that high commodity prices, particularly for oil, are sustaining the services sector, housing, employment and consumer spending.
Monday 30 June 2008 Central bankers warn of inflation scourge
Central bankers issued a stern warning yesterday against the dangers of surging inflation, saying rising energy costs risk damaging growth in rich and poor countries alike.
Sunday 29 June 2008 TORONTO: CREDIT VOTE MAY PROCEED
Ontario Superior Court has ruled that an investor vote on a plan to resuscitate $32 billion worth of frozen asset-backed commercial paper may proceed on Friday as scheduled. The court ruled against parties who wanted a delay, finding that such an eventuality would doom a restructuring plan. The freeze resulted from the international credit crisis that originated with the U.S. high-risk mortgage meltdown last August. Under the plan by the "Pan Canadian" investor committee, short-term ABCP notes would be exchanged for long-term securities in the expectation that by the time they mature, the underlying assets will have recovered all or most of their value. For the plan to succeed, it requires the acquiescence of more than one-half of the votes cast and be approved as well by noteholders representing at least two-thirds of the value of the outstanding notes.
Tuesday Jun 17, 2008 MPs criticize banking regulator
The head of Canada's banking system regulator fended off accusations from MPs yesterday that she and her agency, the Office...
Saturday 14 June 2008 HALIFAX: LAW NEEDED TO PREVENT CANADIAN SUBPRIME ERUPTION
A Nova Scotia-based investment firm says it's necessary to legislate to prevent a repetition in Canada of the worldwide credit crisis that originated in the U.S. last summer from subprime mortgages. Jamie Baillie, the president and CEO of Credit Union Atlantic, says there's no reason why Canada shouldn't have legislation to ban adjustable mortgages by which the rate changes a year later, or mortgages that commence with a monthly payment too small even to cover the monthly interest rate on it. Mr. Baillie says that the subprime borrowers are themselves victims because they are among the most vulnerable members of U.S. society. He also notes that the sellers of such mortgages don't care whether the buyers default because they bundle them with other mortgages in packages sold to Wall Street investment firms, which were badly stung when the flimsy financial instruments collapsed.
LAVAL: PM MORE UPBEAT
Despite the central bank's relative pessimism, Prime Minister Stephen Harper has offered a brighter vision of the country's economic future. Speaking to the Laval Chamber of Commerce, he said that his government's moves to lower income taxes and to reduce the national debt have been crucial to Canada's success in "uncertain economic times." The prime minister concedes that Canada faces challenges from the U.S. economic slump, turbulent credit markets and the drop of the U.S. dollar and acknowledges that economic growth will slow over the next two years.
Sunday 29 June 2008 CALGARY: GAS, OIL PRICES RIDING JUGGERNAUT
A Canadian bank predicts that gasoline and oil prices have only just begun to take off. Canadian Imperial Bank of Canada forecasts that drivers will be paying $1.43 a litre this summer, compared with about $1.23 a litre now, and that it will thus cost about $80 to fill a tank. The report also sees the price of a barrel of crude oil at US$150 by 2010, which will soar to US$225 a barrel four years later.
Saturday 07 June 2008 TORONTO: NON-BANKING PAPER MESS CLOSER TO SOLUTION
Ontario Superior Court has rendered a decision that will be a step toward unfreezing $32 billion of asset-backed commercial paper that has been frozen since August because of the worldwide credit crisis. The court has accepted an amendment that would allow some noteholders under certain conditions to lay claims of fraud against brokerages and dealers who sold them ABCP. The ruling sets the stage for a final phase in the proposed restructuring: a three-week period during which individual and corporate investors may appeal the plan by which the commercial paper in question would be redeemable in several years.
Tuesday 03 June 2008 Canadian Banks - No Need to Buy Yet
RBC CM maintained its cautious view on the bank stocks, reflecting its expectations for continued pressure on profitability, the potential for further negative earnings revisions, and valuations that are not overly cheap on a historical basis given the current challenge. Canadian lifecos are expected to outperform the banks, as the macro environment, while negative, should not impact lifeco earnings as much and is better reflected in valuations. Q2 results were weaker than expected, as core earnings declined a median 4% even when excluding separately disclosed writedowns. RBC CM’s three favourite banks (TD Bank, Royal Bank and Scotiabank) are now rated Sector Perform, as it rates them in the context of its financial services universe. The relatively narrow distribution of ratings also reflects its view that the differentiation between the top and bottom bank stocks will be lower in the next year than it was in the past year. RBC CM has lowered its rating on Royal Bank (RY) from Outperform to Sector Perform given deteriorating credit quality in the bank’s US loan portfolio and slowing retail banking revenue growth.
Saturday 31 May 2008 TORONTO: BANK PROFITS TANK
Canada's biggest banks have had their earnings almost halved in the second quarter to $2.47 billion, compared with last year's second-quarter results. The cause is the credit crunch that start in the U.S. last summer and battered the American housing sector. The crisis has affected consumer spending, corporate lending and mortgages in Canada. On Thursday, the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce reported a $1.1-billion quarterly loss. The banking results published Friday show that the Bank of Nova Scotia has outstripped the Royal Bank as the country's most profitable.
Friday 30 May 2008 US Bank Sector
Thank goodness it’s more bank comments: The latest statistics from the U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) shows recent financial turmoil in the U.S. has caused pain in the banking industry. Commercial banks and savings institutions insured by FDIC reported net income of $19.3 billion in the first quarter of 2008, a decline of $16.3 billion (45.7%) from the $35.6 billion that the industry earned in the first quarter of 2007. The primary reason for the drop of the profits is higher provisions for loan losses as more than half of all insured institutions (50.4%) reported lower net income in the first quarter.
The numbers were better than the Q4 results. FDIC reduced industry earnings for that quarter from the $5.8 billion previously reported to $646 million, as a result of additional charges for goodwill impairment. That is the lowest quarterly net income for the industry since Q4 1990. FDIC is still concerned that: 1) Non-current loans are still rising sharply; 2) Earnings remain burdened by high provisions for loan losses; 3) The industry’s “coverage” ratio – its loss reserves as a percentage of nonperforming loans – continued to erode; and 4) The FDIC’s Deposit Insurance Fund (DIF) reserve ratio fell. Given the crisis is not over, the Federal Reserve announced yesterday that it will make more short-term cash loans available to squeezed banks, marking the latest round in a program that was launched in December to ease stressed credit markets. The Federal Reserve said
it will conduct three auctions in June, with each one making $75 billion available in short-term cash loans.
LIBOR Rate
Doesn’t everyone lie about their number? Several weeks ago we highlighted a Wall Street Journal article, which expressed concern that the very important Libor (London Interbank Offered Rate) was not properly reflecting the actual cost of interbank borrowing. LIBOR is a daily reference rate based on the interest rates at which banks offer to lend unsecured funds to other banks in the London wholesale money market. The difference between the LIBOR rate with the “risk-free” government shortterm money rate is frequently used to measure the perceived health or risk of the banking sector. Everyday at about 11am (London Time) traders from 16 banks report what it would cost them to borrow unsecured money for lengths of time range from overnight to a year. The reported borrowing rate for each participating bank is then published by Thomson Reuters (TRI). The Libor rate is then calculated by averaging the rate for each time period after removing outlier data. The Libor rate sets a benchmark borrowing rate for trillions of dollars of financial instruments globally, including residential mortgages, exotic derivative products and commercial lending. Some market participants and analysts believe that banks are mis-reporting the true costs of their borrowing rate. As each bank’s borrowing rate is published, the banks could be motivated to under report their true borrowing rates, as a higher than average rate would broadly signal to the market that lenders view the bank as having higher than average liquidity risk. The WSJ compared the banks’ self-reported borrowing rate with the credit default insurance and noted that the spread between these number varied greatly with some banks, including Citigroup (C), J.P. Morgan Chase (JPM) and UBS (UBS) – possibly indicating misrepresentation of the Libor rate. Incidentally, the Royal Bank (RY) was noted as one bank who’s published Libor rate was very close to the implied credit insurance risk rate – oh, those honest Canadians.
The WSJ reported that the BBA (British Bankers Association) is expected to meet today to discuss possible djustments to the system, although major changes to the system are not expected.
Friday 23 May 2008 NEW YORK: CENTRAL BANKER WANTS OUNCE OF PREVENTION
The governor of the Bank of Canada, Mark Carney, says the worldwide credit crisis that began last summer with the subprime mortgage uproar in the U.S. is easing. In a speech to the New York Association for Business Economics, Mr. Carney said that central banks need new powers to bring into play the next time that financial institutions start behaving irresponsibly. The central banker says that central banks now have at present the ability to inject liquidity into financial markets when credit grows tight, but that they don't have the means to absorb excess liquidity, as was the case in the period of "easy money" preceding the mortgage eruption. Mr. Carney didn't offer a prediction as to when credit markets will return to normal.
Thursday 22 May 2008 Identify e-mails trying to steal your identity You open your in-box and find e-mail from eBay or PayPal, warning that your account has been compromised by identity thieves and that you must log on immediately to verify your information. more good tips
Articles-by-subject alert: Banking, pensions and financial regulation
From Economist.com, Friday May 16th 2008
The following have been newly published on Economist.com:
Banking's crisis
Banks are bound to fail from time to time. But, asks Andrew Palmer, does the fallout have to be so painful? ... more
Finance in Asia
The credit crisis has cooled Asia's ardour towards Western banks. But the region stands to gain even more from opening up than Wall Street does ... more
Defending the banking system
Modern finance is under attack. Yet the banking system has done much better than it is given credit for ... more
Sunday 04 May 2008 Warren Buffett: big is bad for banks
THE big banks have become too large to manage their own risks properly, Warren Buffett, the world’s most successful investor, warned last night. Their size had led to the recent meltdown in financial markets.
Buffett’s business partner Charlie Munger said a “crazy culture of greed and overreaching” had led to the excesses of the credit crisis and was “counter-productive for the country”.
Burning money
Urban sprawl and the car culture hit Quebecers right in the wallet We all know the impact of the soaring price of oil on our own wallets. But its effect on Quebec's overall prosperity is getting much less attention.
Friday 02 May 2008 OTTAWA: CENTRAL BANK WON'T RESCUE INCOMPETENT FIRMS
The governor of the Bank of Canada, Mark Carney, has warned that the central bank won't intervene to rescue companies in danger of bankruptcy because of unwise business decisions. Mr. Carney told the Senate Committee on banking, Trade and Commerce that the Bank of Canada won't intervene as the U.S. government did when the Bear Stearns investment house became submerged in the subprime mortgage turmoil and that the bank won't help firms that try to maximize profits by ignoring risks. Mr. Carney acknowledges that the central bank has a responsibility as a lender of last resort, but that applies only to institutions that are solvent not those who merely need to be bailed out. On another subject, Mr. Carney dismissed speculation that the economy is headed toward recession, speculation stoked by the revelation on Wednesday that it shrank by .2 per cent in February. The central banker predicts that the economy will slow in the first half but recover in the second.
Sunday 20 April 2008 Don't buy bank shares yet
It looks too early to be buying financial stocks ... After all, the news has been so gloomy, what with the write-downs on mortgage-related bonds, the exposure to a slowing American economy and the crisis at Bear Stearns. Perhaps sentiment has become unduly pessimistic. Richard Cookson of HSBC points out that only three American banks have gone bust so far, compared with 534 in 1989, when the savings and loan crisis was in full swing.
Thursday 17 April 2008 OTTAWA: FINANCE MINISTER CONVOKES BANKERS
Federal Finance Minister Jim Flaherty has called a meeting of the country's top bankers for next week to discuss implementation of financial reforms accepted by the world's top economies. Mr. Flaherty and his six G7 counterparts adopted recommendations put forward by the Financial Stability Forum last weekend. The minister says Canadian regulators and bankers deserve praise for avoiding the deep losses incurred by American and European financial institutions since the subprime mortgage crisis erupted last summer in the U.S. The Financial Stability Forum represents some 60 of the world's strongest economies and made a variety of suggestions aimed at avoiding similar turmoil. These include strengthening the oversight of capital, liquidity and risk management; better valuation of risk; and betterment of the application and uses of credit ratings. Mr. Flaherty says next week's meeting is aimed at ensuring that the reforms are carried out uniformly in Canada.
Tuesday 18 March 2008 Marching to the beat of a different drummer. According to the Wall Street Journal, Royal Bank (RY) was one of a number of
potential buyers that took a look at Bear Stearns (BSC). Other potential buyers included private-equity investors J.C. Flowers,
Kohlberg Kravis Roberts and British bank Barclays PLC. None of whom could put together a deal by Sunday. Was there really
any other option to the JP Morgan’s (JPM) offer? As CNBC’s David Faber said, it was either JP Morgan or bankruptcy for
Bear Stearns. The Fed has a deal with JP Morgan to provided $30 billion in non-recourse financing. If anyone were to buy Bear
Stearns, would the Fed still have been there? The Journal quoted an unnamed person familiar with the sale process in saying,
“The government said you have to do a deal today...we may not be there tomorrow to back you up.” In any case, the Bear
Stearns rescue may be another case of a stronger balance sheet company buying a weaker balance sheet company. If something
like this were to happen in Canada, do you think the Canadian government would finally give in to bank mergers? It was 10
years ago that the Canadian government blocked the merger attempts of four of the country's banks. Royal Bank and Bank of
Montreal (BMO) had plan to merge, as had TD Bank (TD) and CIBC (CM). The Canadian government has appointed a
panel to look into the merger issue and the panel is due to report by mid-year.
Sunday 16 March 2008 Fed Chief Shifts Path, Inventing Policy in Crisis
Ben S. Bernanke, who has long argued that a central bank should act on consistent principles, now has to improvise.
WASHINGTON — As chairman of the Federal Reserve, Ben S. Bernanke has long argued that a central bank should base its policies as much as possible on consistent principles rather than seat-of-the-pants judgment.
BUSINESS Saturday 15 March 2008
Bear Stearns gets emergency funds
US bank Bear Stearns gets emergency funding, raising fears that one of Wall Street's biggest names may collapse.
Fresh banking fears knock shares
US shares fall sharply on renewed fears about the impact of bad mortgage debt and the wider credit squeeze.
Bush reassures over economic woes
President Bush attempts to reassure US businessmen that the country's economy is fundamentally strong.
Friday 14 March 2008 Credit crunch Plugging holes Central banks' latest moves to increase liquidity will ease but not solve the credit crunch
Wednesday 12 March 2008 OTTAWA: CENTRAL BANK AGAIN INTERVENES TO AVERT CREDIT CRISIS
The Bank of Canada has again intervened in tandem with its U.S. and European counterparts to inject cash into financial markets to alleviate the world credit scarcity and to avert recessions. The banks have injected $245 billion overall, Canada's contribution being $4 billion. The central bank says its contribution is relatively modest because Canada's money markets aren't under the same kind of pressure as others. This is the second time since December that the Bank of Canada has intervened in concert with other central banks to make more money available for borrowers.
Friday 07 March 2008 When the rivers run dry
Can bank regulators and central banks prevent future liquidity crises? POLICYMAKERS and academics are still grappling with the causes and consequences of the credit crunch. One broad area of agreement is that ample “liquidity” encouraged the lax lending that led to bad mortgage debts, and a sudden dearth of it helped to precipitate the crisis. But what is liquidity, why does it suddenly evaporate and what can central banks and regulators do to ensure that its ebb and flow does not destabilise economies? This and much else is the subject of a special issue of the Bank of France's Financial Stability Review.*
Monday 28 January 2008 Should Bankers Pay for Their Mismanagement?
From the savings and loan meltdown in the 1980s to the current housing-led seizure, financial institutions have proved unable to curb their appetite for risky assets — blowing up the bank and spreading economic mayhem.
Monday 28 January 2008 Event
Bank share prices have continued under pressure early in 2008, driven by fears of monoline
insurance companies defaulting, recession fears, and concerns about overall financial
market instability.
What It Means
Negative sentiment from headline news and troubled U.S. Financials has more than offset
any comfort investors may have received from the release of solid fourth quarter results by
the Canadian banks and the confirmation of their low exposure to high-risk assets except for
CIBC.
Canadian bank stock price declines have pushed up dividend yields relative to long Canada
bonds to levels never seen before.
We are stress testing bank earnings for a recession again this year following our fiscal 2006
analysis. We believe banks can weather a recession with return on equity troughing in the
17%-18% range. If we cut 2008 earnings to recession levels, banks would be trading at a P/E
multiple of 12.1x with dividend payout ratio of 52%. Thus the current dividend levels are
totally maintainable and defensible. Hence the Best Buying Opportunity in Decades.
We are adjusting modestly our earning estimates and share price targets. Remain
overweight the bank group with TD and RY 1-Sector Outperform.
BUSINESS Saturday 26 January 2008
Worldwide share jitters continue
Global stocks end down on Friday, as concerns return about the state of the worldwide financial sector.
Banks 'may need an extra $143bn'
Banks may need $143bn to weather the credit crisis if bond insurers lose their top credit ratings, new research shows.
Police search rogue trader's bank
French police search the headquarters of Societe Generale, the bank where rogue trading lost huge sums.
Wednesday 23 January 2008 OTTAWA: BANK ACTIONS EASE JITTERS
Central banks in Canada and the United States leapt to the rescue of panicky financial markets Tuesday by chopping interest rates, in the hopes of averting a full-blown recession. In separate but related moves, the Bank of Canada trimmed its key overnight rate by one-quarter percentage point, less than an hour after the U.S. Federal Reserve, acting a week before its scheduled announcement date, axed its target rate by three-quarters of a point. By the end of the day Tuesday, the Toronto Stock Market hadn't quite regained all of Monday's massive losses, but it did make a substantial recovery. The TSX closed up more than 500 points, after losing 605 points Monday. In New York, the Dow rallied from a 457-point deficit to close down 128 points. New York's Nasdaq composite index fell 48 points to 2,292. Economists warn, however, that the interest rate cuts won't be enough to end market turmoil.
Sunday 06 January 2008 OTTAWA: BANK OF CANADA SAYS COFFERS FORGOTTEN
The Bank of Canada says it is seeking some 845,000 people who have abandoned bank accounts worth millions of dollars. Some of the forgotten accounts have been inactive for at least 10 years, and some for as long as 99 years. A statement on the Bank's website says one apparently unknowing Canadian has an unclaimed account worth over $420,000.
2007
Friday Dec 21, 2007 All banks should help to ease credit crisis
The legendary bandit Willie Sutton once told an interviewer that he had chosen to rob banks because "that's where the money is." Bank of Canada Governor David Dodge has better motives but is following the same logic in pressuring Canada's big banks to put their shoulders to the wheel of the asset-backed-commercial-paper crisis.
Wednesday 19 December 2007 Is the banking crisis showing evidence of improving? Nobody wants to touch financials no matter how rattled and “on sale”
they have become. Even in the case of Goldman Sachs (GS) (see our comment below), where they totally beat the street’s
estimates with an excellent quarter. But a couple of favourite gauges of the banking sector are the TED spread and two-month
swap rate spread over Treasuries. The TED spread is the difference between 3-month LIBOR and 3-month Treasuries. It is a
measure of liquidity and shows the flow of dollars into and out of the U.S. It has been rolling down of late, failing to reach the
spread spike peak hit in late August. This is good, as T-Bills are considered to be risk-free, while LIBOR rates spike when
uncertainty and fear increases. The lower the premium for LIBOR, the less premium lenders are demanding. Similar with the
swap-rate premiums relative to the equivalent duration Treasuries. It remains to be seen if the various central bank liquidity
moves will alleviate the stresses. But so far, so good.
Tuesday 11 December 2007 Canadian Banks - Q4 Review
The six banks reported median core EPS growth of 7% from Q4/06 to Q4/07. GAAP earnings were much lower at NA and BMO given the various writeoffs incurred by the two banks. Gains related to the restructuring of Visa masked losses on CDOs and U.S. RMBS at CIBC and RY, and an increase in liability for credit card rewards at RY. TD and CIBC posted the highest growth in core EPS, while NA, RY and BMO were lowest. Retail earnings were short of expectations on greater than anticipated margin pressure, but still up 9% versus Q4/06 on revenue growth of 6%. Wholesale earnings were ahead of RCB CM’s expectations, but they were negatively impacted by capital markets turmoil as GAAP earnings were down 46% versus Q4/06 and 56% sequentially. TD remains least dependent on wholesale earnings, NA and BMO most so. RBC CM believes that key drivers for Canadian bank stocks in 2008 will be growing retail and wealth management businesses, slowing earnings growth, rising risk factors, negative newsflow, and capital ratios.
Friday 07 December 2007 TORONTO: BANK SET EARNING RECORD
Canada's six biggest banks have reported a record profit of $19.5 billion for fiscal 2007, surpassing the previous year's profit of $19 billion. The Bank of Nova Scotia on Thursday was the last to report and racked up a yearly profit of $4.05 billion, also a record. The record figure for the six banks was established despite the losses five of the six suffered in the last quarter due to their involvement in the subprime mortgage crisis in the U.S. Only Toronto Dominion was able to escape the charges.
Thursday 06 December 2007 OTTAWA: CENTRAL BANKER ADVISES AGAINST DOLLAR PEG
The governor-designate of the Bank of Canada, Mark Carney, says it would be a bad idea to peg the value of the Canadian dollar to the U.S. currency or to form a currency union. He told the House of Commons finance committee that he understands the attraction of the idea and that many would like exchange rate certainty to protect sectors like manufacturers. But Mr. Carney says the price would be too high because it would be tantamount to Canada's adopting U.S. monetary policies even though the two economies are very different. The governor-designate says he realizes that the recent volatility of the Canadian currency has been difficult for manufacturers and exporters but the central bank shouldn't intervene except to control inflation.
Thursday 06 December 2007 Royal Bank of Scotland [the only bank Chil Heward likes] announced write-downs of £950m ($1.9 billion) related to subprime-mortgage loans and £250m on leveraged loans capping a dismal few weeks for big banks worldwide, which revealed the initial extent of their losses from the meltdown in credit markets.
Tuesday 04 December 2007 Commercial Banks
Royal Bank’s core cash EPS of $1.00 was below Street estimates of $1.03 and RBC CM’s estimate of $1.05. U.S. and International banking earnings were down 73% versus Q4 as provisions for credit losses rose. Core Canadian banking earnings were up 5%, but slightly below expectations due to loan losses and continued margin compression. The wholesale division was better than expected outside of sub-prime write-offs. Management provided an objective of approximately $4.55-4.65 for cash EPS in 2008, which is slightly above RBC CM’s expectations
Tuesday 20 November 2007 (NA : TSX : $51.80), Net Change: 0.77, % Change: 1.51%, Volume: 818,881
A real ABCPiece of work. National Bank managed to swim through yesterday’s sea of red, despite announcing a $575 pre-tax
charge and before compensation adjustments – we hope this means that the writedowns will negatively affect bonuses. On a net
after-tax basis, this totalled $365 million. National also stated that it bought $2.1 billion of ABCP in Q4, primarily from its own
sponsored mutual funds and pooled funds as well as some owned by its retail clients. This is in addition to the $150 million
National Bank had previously on its balance sheet. It also appears that National took a conservative stance by writing down
more than 25% of its ABCP exposure. The market appeared to cheer this conservative approach. With a Tier 1 ratio of expected
of over its 8.5% target as of October 31, 2007, the liquidity ratio appears to be well above the 7% Tier 1, or core capital, ratio
target required in Canada.
Canadian Banks - Speed Bump Ahead
416 352 4583
Caught in the turmoil gripping the credit markets, the
Canadian Bank Index has fallen 13% from its 2007 high. This is well
below the decline of the US Regional Bank Index (-26% from its 2007
high).
Investors remain spooked over the continuing sub-prime
related write downs of global banks and the potential spill over effect
on the broader economy.
In our view, the losses reported to date for the
Canadian Banks (roughly $2.2 billion pre-tax) pale in comparison with
the massive write-downs announced by some of the US and European banks
and brokers.
On November 27th, Bank of Montreal will start off the
fourth quarter earnings season for the Canadian Banks. We expect the
banks to report solid core earnings, with annual growth (+9% YoY)
underpinned by strong domestic retail and wealth management earnings.
Each of the banks are expected to record flat or sequential declines in
earnings growth (-6.5% QoQ in aggregate) mainly due to weaker wholesale
revenue.
What are the key issues for Q4/07? 1) Ballooning
balance sheets. 2) Write-downs related to current risk exposures and
losses on trading portfolios. 3) Falling, but still strong Tier 1
ratios. 4) Impact of the rising Canadian dollar. 4) NIM compression. 5)
Visa perks.
What are management actions telling us? Think
long-term, this crisis will pass. During the past quarter, three banks
announced major acquisitions: TD Bank with Commerce Bank (US$8.5
billion), Royal Bank with RT&T (US$2.2 billion) and Alabama National
(US$1.6 billion), and Scotiabank with Chilean' Banco del Desarrollo
($1.0 billion).
While we are still in the midst of a restructuring of
the global credit markets, in our view an opportunity is presenting
itself to acquire Canadian Bank shares at a valuation level well below
historical averages. Valuation multiples have compressed in recent weeks
by 2.0 multiple points to 11.0 times trailing earnings. We do not expect
the banks to reach the trough valuations (10.0x trailing earnings) of
the LTCM/ Russian debt crisis.
The rationale for our constructive view on the Canadian
Banks is based on the following: 1) Solid earnings and dividend growth
(8%-10%) is expected for 2008. 2) Lower relative exposure to underlying
credit problems (US sub-prime, CDOs, etc). 3) Positive domestic retail
banking trends driven by upbeat economic and consumer data. 4) Strong
capital ratios in the face of mark-to-market write-downs and expanding
balance sheets.
"Canaccord Capital Corporation <canaccord.com>" made the following
annotations on 11/20/07 16:45:42.
Wednesday 14 November 2007 Canadian Banks - Q4 Preview
The big six Canadian banks report Q4 results between November 27th and December 6th. RBC CM expects TD to grow EPS at the highest rate on industry leading retail growth, a lower relative exposure to wholesale markets, and RBC CM’s belief that it and Scotiabank are less at risk of markdowns in capital markets. Management commentary on the outlook for 2008 is expected to be more important for shares than actual earnings as write-downs in securities portfolios are expected to negatively impact earnings. The turbulence that has caused many global banks and brokers to post disappointing results over the past couple of months will impact Canadian banks, but on a smaller scale. The two banks most exposed to US sub-prime securities are CIBC and Royal Bank, and they stand to benefit the most from the Visa restructuring, so National Bank and Bank of Montreal seem more at risk of being negatively impacted by write-downs on a net basis. RBC CM remains cautious on the banks and continues to prefer lifecos in the near-term.
TORONTO: ROYAL BANK AFFECTED BY SUBPRIME CRISIS
The Royal Bank of Canada says that it too has suffered losses due to its investments in the subprime mortgage market in the U.S. RBC will record a charge of about $360 million for the last quarter of the financial year. Last week, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce and Toronto Dominion Bank announced similar charges. However, RBC foresees a profit of $325 million in its Canadian banking services division for the quarter.
Stephen S. Poloz VP EDC Economics Weekly Commentary Global Forex Flows Titanic - October 24, 2007
Many think of central banks as powerful institutions, able to use their capital to defend their currencies against the uncertain ebbs and flows of the marketplace. But a recent survey by the Bank for International Settlements gives a better idea of what central banks are up against.
The survey covers 54 central banks and monetary authorities and seeks to put parameters around the global foreign exchange market. The individual central banks published their survey results all on the same day. Past issues | his WN page
Friday Oct 5, 2007 National securities regulator urged
The new president of the Canadian Bankers Association reiterated the call for a national securities regulator yesterday, ..."Not only are Canadians paying ... high costs to maintain 13 separate regulatory bodies, the cost to business of complying with 13 sets of rules is also substantial," Nancy Hughes Anthony, who took office this summer, said in a speech to the International Finance Club of Montreal.
Thursday 04 October 2007
Mark Carney, left, at the time a deputy governor of the Bank of Canada, chats with U.S. Federal Reserve chairman Alan Greenspan at a meeting of Group of Seven central bankers and finance ministers, Feb. 6, 2004, in Boca Raton, Fla. (Associated Press/David Adame)
Tuesday 18 September 2007 Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) announced this morning that it will acquire 18% of DundeeWealth (DW), with the right to acquire up to 20%. The Bank will purchase 27.3 million newly-issued common shares and non-voting shares at $12.76 for $348 million.
Saturday 01 September 2007 TORONTO: SCOTIABANK EXPANDS IN CHILE
A Canadian bank has agreed to buy a 79-percent stake in Chile's Banco del Desarrollo. The Bank of Nova Scotia will pay US$810 million for the purchase. The Toronto-based bank says it plans to later acquire the rest of the South American country's seventh-largest bank. The purchase will increase Scotiabank's market presence in what it calls one of the most developed and attractive markets in Latin America.
Friday 31 August 2007 National Bank of Canada (NA : TSX : $55.97)
Posts better-than-expected third-quarter results
Blackmont Capital maintains a "hold", 12-month target price is $67.50
Wednesday 29 August 2007 Bank of Montreal (BMO) - $65.65 - Solid Q3 Results, Key Trends Unchanged
Underperform, Average Risk - Price Target: $69.00
BMO reported core cash EPS of $1.46, ahead of the consensus estimate of $1.39. The upside was primarily due to strong growth in capital markets and in the private client division. The bank continues to reduce the size of the commodities portfolio and its risk, however RBC CM estimates that there are approximately 2 quarters to go before the size of the portfolio is reduced to an acceptable level. BMO raised its dividend by $0.02 to $0.70 per share. RBC CM believes that BMO is likely to underperform its Canadian peers as its retail revenue continues to lag the group and the bank derives a higher proportion of its earnings from wholesale banking.
TORONTO: BMO FACING INQUIRIES OVER COMMODITY LOSS
The Bank of Montreal says it has received a series of inquiries and requests for information in relation to its report of serious losses in commodities trading, particularly in natural gas. The losses stemmed from advice from a New York brokerage house, Optionable Inc. BMO is one of the firm's main customers. The bank says the inquiries have come from securities, commodities, banking and law enforcement officials. BMO says that since the proceedings are in early stages, it cannot say whether there will be any legal action against it but that it is co-operating. The bank also announced third-quarter profit of $660 million, down 7.1 from a year earlier.
Monday 27 August 2007 Royal Bank of Canada (RY : TSX : $55.05), Net Change: -0.38, % Change: -0.69%, Volume: 2,958,461
“Yes, Homer. It’s true that I have everything a man could ever want but I would give it up...for just a little more.” – Mr.
Burns. Canada’s largest lender reported profits for the 11th-straight quarter and beat analysts’ estimates, thanks to higher mutual
fund sales and investment-banking fees. Third quarter income was up to $1.4 billion ($1.06 per share), an increase of 19% yearover-
year. Analysts expected only $1.03 in EPS. Royal Bank also raised its dividend by 9% to $0.50 per share, its fourth
increase in two years. There was a 30% increase in profits from asset management, as well as stronger fees from M&A and
underwriting (both of which should slow considerably in Q3). Last Thursday, Toronto-Domion (TD) saw its earnings jump
39%. As well as the big banks are doing, the likes of Ontario Teachers Pension and the Province of Ontario are considering their
“legal options” in having had the rug pulled in the asset-back debacle. Dundee’s Ned Goodman put it the strongest when he
criticized the major bikes bluntly: “It’s a monopoly, it’s a cartel, it’s an oligopoly. The thing they did a few days ago – where
they all gathered together, saying, ‘If you deal with us, you’re good, if you dealwith anybody else [like Coventree], you’re not’
– just proves that it’s an oligopoly.” The near future should be very interesting.
Wednesday 30 May 2007 Scotia Bank (BNS) - $54.25 – Strong Results Sector Perform, Average Risk – Price Target: $57.00 Scotia reported better than expected Q2 results yesterday, with core cash EPS of $1.02 vs. the consensus of $0.95. Results were ahead of expectations in all three operating divisions. The quarterly dividend was raised from $0.42 to $0.45. RBC CM increased its EPS estimate from $3.95 to $4.05 for 2007 and from