McGill University's board of governors has voted to require managers
of its endowment fund to divest stocks of any companies doing harm in
Myanmar.
It is the first time McGill has taken such a stand since
it divested stocks of companies operating in South Africa in the
mid-1990s.
The decision, in response to pressure from students
and faculty members, shows how the socially responsible investment
movement is gaining traction on university campuses.
Myanmar,
formerly known as Burma, has become one of the world's worst
human-rights abusers. Its military rulers have clung to power after
refusing to accept the results of a 1990 democratic election in which
the National League for Democracy won an overwhelming majority.
Since
then, they've waged a campaign of systematic repression and have kept
NLD leader and Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi under house arrest.
McGill's
decision won't change its endowment holdings for now, acknowledges Ian
Soutar, a Montreal investment manager who advises the university on
matters of social responsibility.
Soutar said the university
reviewed the portfolios run by its investment managers and determined
it didn't own stocks in two companies that do business with the
military regime: French oil giant Total and Canadian-owned company
Ivanhoe Mines.
"As it turns out, to the best of our knowledge, none of (our) accounts own shares in these two companies.
"But
at the same time, if we identify other companies in Burma that are
aiding and abetting this quite illegitimate military regime that's
taken over from a democratically elected government, we might (take
action) as well.
"We think it's a bad place and we think it's important that McGill stands up and makes a statement here."
The
interesting question is whether the Myanmar decision will set a
precedent that's difficult to live with for those who manage the
university's more than $700-million endowment.
Everybody has a
favourite crusade on a university campus, whether it's tobacco,
gambling, pharmaceuticals, Third World sweatshops or clear-cutting.
Indeed,
the next cause gaining support at McGill is for the university to
divest shares of companies operating in war-torn Sudan.
Soutar
admits while this is the first time McGill has adopted a divestment
policy since the South Africa issue came to a head, it's unlikely to be
the last, given the growing strength of the corporate-responsibility
movement.
Portfolio managers, by and large, do a good job of investing in a responsible manner, he says.
"But we've got to be careful in terms of tying the hands of our portfolio managers.
"I
know, being an investment manager myself, if your clients start to tell
you too much about how you're going to run your portfolios, it's not
going to help, because you can't run them all differently.
"We want to be realistic."
"The
other question is whether divestiture really does anything in terms of
helping people in those countries," he says, and "there's two sides to
that story."
The presentation to the board by McGill's Myanmar group noted that several universities in the U.S. have already taken action on the issue.
Harvard and Stanford both cancelled contracts with Pepsi because of that company's involvement in Myanmar.
The
University of Minnesota divested from Total, and the University of
Virginia sold off shares in Unocal, another oil and gas company
operating in the country.
McGill's decision concerns two
controversial projects under fire from Myanmar activists: the Yadana
gas pipeline and the Monywa copper mine.
Total is participating in the Yadana project in partnership with the state-owned Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise.
"The
Burmese Army provided security for this project, which resulted in
serious violations of human rights," stated the presentation by the
McGill activists.
Vancouver-based Ivanhoe Mines is a
joint-venture partner with the Myanmar regime in the Monywa copper
mine, where "forced labour was used to construct rail and power
infrastructure," the McGill group says.
On Ivanhoe's website, the
company claims the project is either "misunderstood or deliberately
misrepresented" and says it has many supporters in Myanmar whOWN it
to remain there.
phadekel@videotron.ca
© The Gazette (Montreal) 2006