|
Read About W-N
NP story on W-N
Contact W-N and Map
Invite to Wed1308
Wednesday Night Salon
#1308 28 Mar 2007 Page 2
I think it is very particular to find [a place] where people still have the passion to exchange and discuss ideas especially in a world that is now full of manipulation, branding, polls and 45-second sound bites Yves Séguin
Introduction
As might be expected, following the somewhat tumultuous events of Monday night, a full house of political and economic junkies, many of whom are experts in their respective fields, greeted the welcome return to Wednesday Night of Yves Séguin, former Minister of Finance of Québec. Intro Wed1308 by Diana Nicholson & Hans Black to Yves Séguin.wmv 10:21 video
"Let me compliment you both on the valuable session we had last night. For me, it was confirmation of a long-held suspicion that the Quebec march into increasing debt has no remedy in sight. We may have ignored the environment, but as potential disasters go, we did well enough." Tony (Deutsch)
(March 29, 2007)
The Federal Budget and the Québec election
The combined significance of the Flaherty (federal) budget (the "best crafted in history" according to more than one Wednesday Nighter and one which will win the Harper government a majority in the next election) and the electoral shattering of the two traditional mainstream parties in the Québec election towards favouring a young, more conservative government here, is of monumental importance. The influence of the federal budget should not be underestimated; most likely it ensured that the PLQ achieved at least minority government status. Jacqes Clément, Yevs Séguin & Peter Trent 7:19 video on Debt & TAX Unlisted (link from w-n only)
For the first time, Quebeckers have clearly rejected parties promising tax cuts and/or a new shot at independence in favour of a more right wing National Assembly. Whether intended or not, it would appear that the federal Conservative budget addressing, for the first time, fiscal imbalance, by giving Québec $12.9 billion in 2006-07, $15.2 billion in 2007-08 and $16.3 billion in 2008-09 in transfer payments, may have had a hand in the change in this province and is expected by many to ensure a Conservative majority government in Ottawa in soon-to-be-called elections. The outcome of the next federal election is expected to see the Bloc considerably reduced in numbers and Stéphane Dion out as Leader of the Liberal party, following a Liberal Party convention.
For the first time the true worth of each province has been taken into consideration in the redistribution process, including the total wealth of each, fair market value of real estate and all revenue including offshore oil revenue in Newfoundland, as well as continuing debt repayment. This approach was likely strongly influenced by the report of the Commission on Fiscal Imbalance in 2002, which was chaired by tonight's guest. Hans Black & Peter Trent Trains 5:02 video Unlisted (link from w-n only)
Debt – good bad or ugly?
Following Canada’s financial crunch a decade ago, the Chrétien government’s initiatives resulted in successive large surpluses, permitting Ottawa to pay down debt in a spectacular manner. The current Harper government has chosen to put some of the surplus into tax reduction and to address the issue of fiscal imbalance, apparently important issues for the population, virtually assuring a majority Conservative government following the expected forthcoming federal election.
Are we too fiscally prudent?
While apparently the majority of Canadians applaud these measures, some question the wisdom of neglecting the education deficit and the problem of renewal of infrastructure, especially that relating to the transportation of goods and humans, in order to pay down debt at 4½% - 5%, pointing out that borrowing money in order to pay for the modernization of crumbling infrastructure is not necessarily a wise choice when raw materials prices are rising at around 13% compounded. Another, often overlooked element of infrastructure investment is communications.
While transportation infrastructure is a popular topic, it is also true that a more wired society is a more competitive society, therefore should we not also be investing in telecommunications infrastructure? Can this be accomplished through public/private partnership as is happening in Alberta?
- I think we are in a longer cycle of increasing infrastructure costs
- You don’t get brownie points for getting our debt down with our infrastructure falling apart and medical care in shambles
The Québec budget
The 2008-2009 Québec budget starts with a debt of over one billion dollars. If the accumulated deficits of health care facilities and school boards were included, the provincial debt would have reached $6.6 billion and if other debts such as those of municipalities, universities and Hydro Québec were also included, the total debt would actually reach $193 billion for a population of 7.5 million where just half of the citizens pay tax.
Jacqes Clément, Yevs Séguin & Peter Trent 7:19 video on Debt & TAX Unlisted (link from w-n only)
Although we are putting money into the fonds des générations, which is certainly desirable, we continue to borrow at an increasing rate while 52% of citizens pay either no tax or pay less that $500 per year, and that number is increasing by 1% every five years. With fewer taxpayers contributing, the government has borrowed five billion dollars this year (compared to $2.5 billion under the previous PQ government) and a total of fourteen billion over the last four years. Sixty-five percent of the total Québec budget is payroll; add to that another 15% for buildings. At the very least, productivity among the civil servants must be increased and this will inevitably bring on confrontation with unions. It is not likely that a minority government will take on that challenge.
Certainly, addressing the fiscal imbalance is an important first step with more to be done in order to address this problem, but in this campaign, not one of the leaders was willing to take a hard line, preferring the Santa Claus approach. But who will print the money? The last-minute promise by Mr. Charest to reduce income tax is an empty promise, because reduction of taxes will lead to higher fees. It would have been more appropriate to use the money for healthcare or education. The Québec government will have to establish priorities, while responding to the regions, which at the same time want smaller government, but all the services they currently enjoy. Harsh realities hit home in Quebec
Election a 'real wake-up call,' Jarislowsky says
- In a number of European countries, this is referred to as 'fiscal alcoholism'. In dealing with it, you have to increase taxes or cut expenditures, both of which are politically very painful
- Can we change society to accept the views of Les Lucides , or is that an impossible task?
- What part in cutting government deficits can be played by making government more efficient overall?
- It has been calculated that tax (PST) evasion on home renovations in Québec amounts to a total amount of uncollected tax of $1billion – if Québec were to give a tax deduction on renovations of up to $10,000, it could be expected that most would pay the taxes and declare the expense in order to claim the rebate - the cost to Québec would be roughly $12 million
How is a budget crafted?
Choices between the rational and the politically desirable, make the work of Finance Minister and the Deputy Minister extremely challenging. Unfortunately, it is quite unusual to see a good match between the Minister and his department. The budget is most often the product of the personalities involved, and often depends on the Minister. In Québec, some 100 people work on the budget, and normally it is the Deputy Minister who serves as the go-between the Minister and the worker bees. Thus, the minister has no opportunity to discuss and debate scenarios with other levels of the civil service.
In the ideal situation, the Minister, the Deputy Minister and a fairly large number of key civil servants massage the various parts of the budget, in order to arrive at the optimum if not the best means of attaining financial as well as political goals as determined by the Prime Minister and cabinet; not a simple task.
In Ottawa, the process has been quite different, with weekly meetings starting in early September, between the Deputy Minister and the Prime Minister's Chief of Staff, while in Québec it is more likely that the Minister of Finance discuss directly with the Premier's office.
In either case, obviously, it is the Prime Minister (Premier) who has the final say.
Perhaps the best guideline is for the minister to ask himself, "can I explain this to my mother or father? If I don't understand it well enough to explain it to them and answer their questions, then there's something wrong".
The world economy
The crystal ball is clouded but financial and geopolitical problems could make matters even more difficult for our governments. The U.S. is heading for a soft landing, followed by a hard landing and possibly recession. The mortgage market in that country is in disarray. The economy is weakening in Europe and global growth is slowing. France is not doing well, Germany may surprise, but only for another quarter or two. The constant threat of overdue global disaster, very possibly the avian flu, or a widening Iran crisis, does not bode well for the continued unbridled growth that we currently experience. Jacques Clement & HansBlack Mkts to go down 8:36 video Yves Séguin & Peter Trent
NYT: Front Page for Wednessday 28 Mar |
27 Mar Tue |
26 Mar Mon |
22 Mar Thur
Thursday 29 March 2007 To day NYT Podcast | Menu
Radio
Like the report of Mark Twain's death, reports of the death of radio –at least FM – are greatly exaggerated.
More links on related topics
The election may not have made it to the BBC, but the Economist carries an analysis dated March 29 Au revoir separatism, bonjour “autonomy”
Quebec's voters have turned their province's politics upside down, and may have reshaped those of Canada
Will the ADQ replace the PQ ?
Mario Dumont’s ambivalent nationalism is a convenient, yet dignified, exit from the sovereignist agenda, says LYSIANE GAGNON
The disconnect between Quebec francophones and Canada
Jeffrey SIMPSON The Globe and Mail 27 mars 2007
The Quebec election results - a feeble Liberal minority - illustrate the continuing disengagement of the province’s francophones from Canada. Where this will lead is unknown, but this disengagement will intensify demands for more power and money for Quebec. Jeffrey Simpson
Quebec political figures push for proportional representation
What will happen to the price of oil?
Real estate
Canadian dollar is expected to decline against its U.S. counterpart.
The economy
See also JACQUES CLEMENT: Pages ON THE ECONOMY
Previous Videos
Notes by Herb Bercovitz OWN
Editor: Diana Thébaud Nicholson OWN
Radio, the long-lasting treasure
intro Wed1308 | Wed1308 slide show
Oil
Note
Wednesday-Night creates charts and follows stocks, including timely related financial news items, in which Wednesday Nighters are interested and in order to demonstrate a service that could eventually be developed and marketed. Wednesday Nighters are invited to participate and help to test the service.
see Wednesday-Night.com Flip charts
QUOTES of the EVENING from recent
Wednesday Nights
2007
Past Quotes Best or All
W-N Links for #1308
2007 Notes for #1308
Rex Murphy's
Point of View index
Menu to mitworld.mit.edu/ on-demand videos of significant public events at MIT. in RealPlayer
Ex Thomas L. Friedman. While you were Seeping The World IS Flat Video length is 1:15:04.
 Stephen S. Poloz VP EDC Economics Weekly Commentary
Canada Losing Ground in Trade - March 28, 2007
The importance of trade to Canadian prosperity has increased a lot in the past 40 years. Since the dawn of the new millennium, though, Canada has been losing ground in the trade domain.
Canada?s total exports of goods and services were worth $524 billion in 2006, of which $459 billion were goods and $65 billion in services. This was an increase of only 1% over 2005, after growth of 5.1% in 2005 and 7.1% in the boom year, 2004. 2006 was slow, it is true, but it is worth recalling that Canada?s exports saw an extended period of decline just a few years ago: during 2001-2003, Canada?s exports fell outright three years in a row, cumulatively by about 6%. Past issues | his WN page
Commentary podcast. 
Thursday 29 March 2007 To day NYT Podcast | Menu
Wednesday-Night.com on Privacy
Canadian dollar vs euro | Dow 30 w-n chart | TSX
Fed Parties Stéphan Dion | Stevie Harper
see also Wednesday-Night.com MedicalNotes
| 
BBC
Au revoir separatism, bonjour “autonomy” 
; "DTN Chair by Robert J. Galbraith")
; "click for Diana Nicholson OWN")
 "Louise des Trois Maisons")
; "click Jacques Clément OWN")
 "click for Diana T. Nicholson")
; "click for Herb Bercovitz OWN")
Wed1308 report 
Wed1308